The Ballad of Jack and Rose (4/5/12)

Ballad of Jack and RoseMovie Seventy Five

The Ballad of Jack and Rose presents a very simple premise with incredibly complex characters and subject matter. While it certainly isn’t for everyone, I would recommend watching it for Daniel Day-Lewis alone.

Daniel Day-Lewis has firmly secured his place as one of the greatest actors of our time by getting entirely enveloped in his role. For The Ballad of Jack and Rose he plays a protective father with a Scottish accent living in a secluded area that is threatened by commercialization. If I didn’t know any better, I would have sworn he was actually Scottish (he’s English) he is just so transcendent, even in the mildest of roles.

In the film, Jack (Day-Lewis) lives alone with his teenage daughter on a secluded island where he used to be a commune leader. He falls ill and his daughter Rose (Camilla Belle) becomes jealous when he asks another woman and her sons to stay with them. It’s as much a story about family as it is a coming-of-age story.

One thing that people seem to associate with this film is incest and that isn’t completely untrue. The years spent together, isolated from the rest of the world, has stunted the emotional growth of Rose and she confuses the love of a family member with sexual love. There is nothing graphic in the film and the scenes that encounter the issue do so without being blunt about it. It isn’t a matter of being sexually attracted to her father, it’s more jealousy and confusion. The story is about the love of a father and daughter, but not the sexual relationship between a father and daughter, if that helps clarify things.

Regardless of the kind of gross nature of this, I would recommend the The Ballad of Jack and Rose. The story is original while staying familiar and the acting is top-notch, especially from Daniel Day-Lewis. Don’t let the horror stories about the incestuous nature keep you from watching what is otherwise a fairly entertaining and touching story.

I give it 3 Paul Dano midriffs out of 5.


Rotten Tomatoes


11 responses to “The Ballad of Jack and Rose (4/5/12)

  1. Great review man. I really liked this film also. The critics gave it a bit a panning, which I thought unfair. totally agree on Day-Lewis. The Man’s a master. One of my all time favourites. Did you know, it was his wife that wrote and directed it? She also happens to be related to playwright Arthur Miller.

    • Thanks!
      When I was looking it up on IMDB I wondered if she was related to Arthur Miller, but had no idea it was Day-Lewis’ wife. Pretty awesome stuff. I could literally watch him in anything.

      • Aye, I think his wife is either the daughter or granddaughter of Arthur Miller. Can’t remember now. Being Scottish myself I found Day-Lewis’ Scottish accent in this, spot on. Too many actors exaggerate the accent, making it stereotypical but he nails it. Johnny Depp’s attempt at it in Finding Neverland was also rather good. I digress though, Day-Lewis is in my top three of actors. The others being DeNiro and the very underrated Bridges (Jeff that is, not Beau) 😉

  2. I would recommend watching it for Daniel Day-Lewis alone. – great statement

    I don’t care what he does – reading a phone book – I’ll be there. He can take a simple role and make it grand.

  3. Pingback: April Movies Round-Up | Andy Watches Movies

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s